Back to Collection
The Peanut Butter

Sturdy & Nutty

The Peanut Butter

A sturdy, old-fashioned peanut butter cookie with a rich, nutty bite and a tender crumb. Made with creamy peanut butter and rich grass-fed butter, each cookie is thick and robust with a smooth golden top and a single peanut nestled in the center. Golden-edged and deeply peanutty, finished with a touch of sea salt. Each cookie weighs just over 2 ounces.

Texture Map

ExteriorGolden & Crosshatched
Mid-LayerSturdy & Tender
CoreNutty Peanut Center

Warming Instructions

Warm at 300°F for 3-4 minutes. Let rest 60 seconds before serving.

Key Ingredients

Creamy Peanut Butter, Grass-fed Butter, Unbleached Flour, Brown Sugar, Cane Sugar, Organic Eggs, Organic Madagascar Vanilla Extract, Sea Salt, Peanuts

Allergen Information

DairyWheatEggs

All products are made in a kitchen that handles nuts, dairy, wheat, eggs, and soy. Please contact us before ordering if you have severe allergies.

Qty1
$28.00per dozen cookies
MAMA TARA'S

Handcrafted gourmet cookies and brownies, born in the Sonoran desert and delivered fresh across Tucson.

Delivery

Central Tucson

Midtown

East Tucson

Northeast Tucson

Foothills

© 2026 Mama Tara's Cookie and Brownie Delivery. Tucson, Arizona.

CRAFTED WITH HEAT & INTENTION

This product was produced in a home kitchen that may come in contact with common food allergens and pet allergens and is not subject to public health inspection.

Product images are AI-generated for illustration and may not match the actual cookies exactly.